Pie in the Sky Bakery

Menu

Slice of peach pie.

Pies by the slice $4.95

Enjoy a generous slice of any of our pies in the shop, or take a slice to go. You'll always find classic favorites like our signature Chess Pie, All-American Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Puddin' (Chocolate Creme), Banana Creme, Lemon Meringue, and Dixie Pecan, as well as seasonal specials like Strawberry Rhubarb, Georgia Peach, Shoofly, Pumpkin, or Royal Mincemeat.

Slice of cherry pie and ice cream.

À la mode $1.25 per scoop

Top any slice of pie with a scoop of ice cream! Choose from French vanilla, chocolate fudge, dulce de leche, mocha chip, mint chocolate chip, sweet cherry, and no-sugar-added vanilla (sweetened with Splenda tm). All ice cream flavors are also available by the pint ($4.95) to take home.

Little pies!

Mini-pies $8

When one slice just isn't enough! Our 6" mini-pies are sized to share. Perfect for a romantic picnic or as the finishing touch for a dinner for two. Kids can't agree on a flavor? Two mini-pies are the ticket to family harmony.

Whole lemon meringue pie.

Whole pies $14.95

Need a quick and delicious dessert? Our whole pies serve six. They're the perfect ending to a weeknight meal or a weekend barbeque. (They make a great breakfast treat too!) Don't forget to pick up a pint of our ice cream - the ideal accompaniment to our delectable pies.